Atherton resident calls for probe of police department Atherton, posted by Editor, The Almanac Online, on Feb 2, 2010 at 7:17 pm
An Atherton resident who said he was wrongfully arrested in 2008 on domestic violence charges was exonerated Jan. 14 by a San Mateo County Superior Court judge. Now, he's publicly calling for an investigation into the Atherton Police Department's practices.
Read the full story here Web Link posted Wednesday, February 3, 2010, 12:00 AM
Posted by Bizarre, a resident of the Atherton: other neighborhood, on Feb 3, 2010 at 1:39 am
Ed, couldn't have said it better. Picking up on Mr. Hine's comment on the sister thread, what is Town Square for? You write an article about a guy and he makes one very factual comment and you lock down the item? It seemed to me that he had a right to do that since the original article had that allegation yet you then deleted items referring to it (police report tampering or alteration) saying it was unfounded. It seemed like you challenged his credibility and he should have the right to respond to that challenge.
Posted by Michael G. Stogner, a resident of another community, on Feb 3, 2010 at 6:36 am
Another place to report the facts about Atherton.
San Mateo Daily Journal Community Forum
I have been posting there for several years about very serious subjects. At one time they did shut the entire site down (40 days) and deleted all of my articles/posts. Things have changed for the better and I recommend that site.
A recent example you will see: Stogner trys, I am so thankful that I spotted this post and moved it when I did.
Posted by unanswered questions, a resident of the Atherton: other neighborhood, on Feb 3, 2010 at 8:03 am
You locked the other post before we received a reply from Ms. Gemmet to the question posed by Amateur Editor.
As was accurately recounted by Amateur Editor, an Atherton Police officer who shall remain nameless testified in open court that his police report has been altered.
This is not the first time that a police report being altered in recent memory. Officer Clark Yee was prosecuted by Mr. Wagstaffe on the very same grounds. Hence it stands to reason that Mr. Wagstaffe would seek justice in Mr. Buckheit\'s matter as well. (Please pardon the digression.)
Ms. Gemmet referred to Mr. Buckheit\'s allegation as just that, an allegation. Ms. Gemmet failed to acknowledge that Mr. Buckheit did not make an allegation. Mr. Buckheit made a statement of fact which are documented in court transcripts.
Ms. Gemmet also quoted Mr. Wagstaffe in paraprashing the comments of Judge Forcum. It appears as though Ms. Gemmet was not curious enought to inquire as to whether Mr. Wagstaffe was in the courtroom (he was not) or whether he read the transcript.
I respectfully submit that lazy journalism is shoddy journalism. I respectfully submit to you that we, the readers of your paper deserve an explanation from Ms. Gemmet.
I await your reply Mr. Hine should Ms. Gemmet be to shy to speak for herself.
Posted by Michael G. Stogner, a resident of another community, on Feb 4, 2010 at 8:23 pm
For those Atherton residents serious about your Town.
Mr. Jon Buckheit has been very straight forward to the Council, City Manager, and Police Chief about what he expected to happen by tomorrow. It is unfortunate for all of you that your Police Chief is unwilling to identify the officer or officers who committed a Felony against him. Lets think how hard could this be you only have 12 officers, you subtract the original officer who testified a crime had been committed that leaves 11 including the Chief.
If he can't solve that crime I think that says it all.
Posted by Candle Lighter, a resident of the Atherton: West Atherton neighborhood, on Feb 5, 2010 at 12:14 am
It is a clear conflict of interest for the Atherton Police or San Mateo District Attorney to investigate this police report tampering incident. It's simply equivalent to asking the fox if the henhouse is okay. Watergate started with some relatively stupid petty crimes and turned into a national scandal of historical proportions through the cover-up that ensued. I expect this incident to turn into a similarly-scaled scandal for Atherton for the same reasons. Pres. John F. Kennedy was found of stating "a mistake doesn't become a problem until you fail to correct it."
Posted by Michael G. Stogner, a resident of another community, on Feb 5, 2010 at 5:24 am
POLICE REPORTS ARE NOT CONFIDENTIAL DOCUMENTS.
Thomas Casey III, Counsel for San Mateo County, said yesterday that Attorney General Bill Lockyerís office found that the allegations made by Ramona Gatto against District Attorney Jim Fox and Assistant District Attorney Morley Pitt were without basis.
"He said the attorney generalís finding underscores the fact that police reports are not confidential documents,"
"Matty Hrncir, who once worked as a detective in the elite Sexual Assaults Investigations Unit, could face criminal charges in a highly unusual probe that potentially implicates the officer, a nine-year veteran, of a felony charge of filing false police reports, according to her lawyer, Terry Bowman."
"Assistant Police Chief Daniel Katz on Friday confirmed that San Jose investigators delivered the case to the district attorney's office earlier this month for possible prosecution."
"Police departments have a responsibility to clean up their own house, and if they feel there is a problem with an officer, they should investigate it thoroughly," said William Rapoport, a veteran San Mateo County lawyer who specializes in law enforcement. "If the case has merit, submitting it for prosecution is beneficial to the department and the community at-large and to the judicial system.''