Red Light Cameras ineffective in reducing violations
Original post made by Roger Jones on May 20, 2013
May 20, 2013
Sgt. Sharon Kaufman
Menlo Park Police Dept.
Dear Sgt. Kaufman,
When we talked last week I said extending yellow light times would reduce red light running whereas massive enforcement does not and will not accomplish this primary goal except for an initial period of time. Mark Riggs of Redflex said pretty much the same thing.
I call your attention to the signal light at Bayfront Expressway and Willow Rd. In July of 2010, the yellow light for the left turn lanes was extended from 3.0 to 3.5 seconds to allow motorists who approach at speeds far above 25 mph enough time to recognize the change to yellow and to come to a complete stop.
And what have been the results of this seemingly insignificant change?
With the short 3.0 second yellow, violations averaged 213 per month for the 12 month period before the change. After the change? Violations in the 27 months following the change averaged only 80 per month. In fact, the average would have been even lower, 64 per month, had not there been nearly triple the number of violations in 3 of the last 4 months in the study period.
Throwing out those 3 recent months of June, July, and August of 2012 where violations tripled, Menlo Park experienced a 70% reduction to red light running at this location.
You steadfastly insist there will be rebound effect. There has been none so far. If you can spot one, please let me know. It has been nearly 3 years. Still waiting?
Let's not lose sight of the fairness issue. What of those over 2,000 motorists who needlessly were cited for being 1/2 second late or less before the change was made? Tickets with fines and fees exceeding one million dollars ($1,000,000)? What were they guilty of? Being human? Having normal reaction/perception reaction times? I would say they were obeying Newton's laws which say objects moving at higher rates of speed need more time to stop.
Red Light Camera Protest Group
p.s. Would you know what would account for a tripling of violations in June, July, and August of 2012?
cc: City Council of Menlo Park
If you were a member and logged in you could track comments from this story.
Marché's Guillaume Bienaimé to open downtown Palo Alto restaurant
By Elena Kadvany | 8 comments | 2,945 views