Judge OKs release of report on Atherton's fired finance chief


The investigator's report that led to Atherton Finance Director John Johns' being fired must be released to the public, San Mateo County Superior Court Judge John Runde ruled Friday.

However, Judge Runde granted a 10-day stay of his order in case Mr. Johns chooses to file an appeal. If there is no appeal, the report becomes public on Dec. 10.

Mr. Johns, a town employee since 2001, has called the investigator's report inaccurate, and sought to prevent its release via a preliminary injunction. If made public, the report would harm his reputation and his future employment prospects, he said.

Mr. Johns also filed a wrongful termination claim against the town seeking $500,000 in damages.

Last month, a judge granted a temporary restraining order preventing the report from being released to the Almanac newspaper in response to the Almanac's California Public Records Act request of Oct. 31.

At the hearing on Nov. 30, Judge Runde ruled that a redacted version of the personnel report could be released, but not the exhibits, including 60 pages of pictures, that accompany the report.

The personnel investigation of Mr. Johns, conducted by attorney Mary Topliff, was triggered by a hostile workplace complaint filed by Atherton Police Chief Bob Brennan in May.

Mr. Johns' attorney, George Camerlengo, argued that the investigation report, and Mr. Johns' subsequent firing on Oct. 29, was in retaliation for his work uncovering problems in the Atherton's building department and uncovering "preferential treatment to three of the City Council members, in terms of their building permits."

"This man cleaned up (Atherton's) finances, he tried to clean up the building department, he got the town operating in the black," Mr. Camerlengo said. "He stepped on some toes in the process and now the town is chomping at the bit to release (the report)."

Attorneys for Atherton argued that the public's right to know about the conduct of a public official outweighs any right to privacy Mr. Johns might have.

"Mr. Johns made himself a public figure and waived a reasonable expectation of privacy," said Atherton City Attorney Marc Hynes, citing an Almanac article that quoted Mr. Johns saying that, as Atherton's second-longest serving department head, he was well-qualified for the city manager job.

The City Council is in the midst of interviewing city manager candidates, following the retirement of City Manager Jim Robinson in July.

Atherton co-counsel Louis Leone also argued that because Mr. Johns gave copies of the investigator's report to three people, he effectively published it and made it a public document. Mr. Camerlengo countered that Mr. Johns was seeking the advice of three people involved in the investigation, and that none of them had read the report.

A "friend of the court" letter, filed by the California First Amendment Coalition executive director Peter Scheer, argued that blocking release of the report deprives the town of Atherton from communicating with the public.

"Whatever aspersions (Mr. Johns) may cast on the conduct and motivations of the town only heighten the public concern in the dispute," Mr. Scheer wrote. "Depriving the government of its right to disseminate that information, and the public of its right to seek and obtain it, cannot be justified on the basis of the speculation and conjecture that (Mr. Johns) has offered in support of his request for injunctive relief."

The fact that Atherton officials had intended to release the report on Mr. Johns is a dramatic change from last year, when even City Council members had to fight to get access to a report from an investigation into the conduct of building department staff.

Mr. Hynes told the Almanac that recent judicial decisions paved the way for public disclosure of reports on management employees such as Mr. Johns and former Building Official Mike Hood, but not of rank-and-file employees. A 2006 investigator's report on Mr. Hood should be released in early December, Mr. Hynes said.


Like this comment
Posted by Michael G Stogner
a resident of another community
on Dec 1, 2007 at 11:22 am

This story is growing every minute.

Inspector Ivan Grosshauser, of San Mateo County District Attorney's Office was present at the hearing yesterday, It was mentioned in court that there is an active criminal investigation on going against Mr. John Johns....Also present was Town of Atherton Police Chief Bob Brennan.

You will recall he (Chief Bob) stated he had done a routine computer background check on Mr. John Johns for some unknown reason and discovered that his California drivers license had expired...Instead of letting the ex-Finance Director of the Town of Atherton know about this lapse, he instead ordered Mr.Johns to get in his car, start the engine, turn off the engine, get out of the car, and receive a Fix It Ticket.....

Atherton co-counsel Louis Leone, had stated to the court that he had been taking depositions on Tuesday and Wednesday of this week...What he didn't say was that a Town of Atherton worker by the name of Tim Wulff was scheduled for Tuesday at 2:PM. Mr. Wulff found an Atherton Police Officer on his property at 7:40 AM that Tuesday looking at his car.APD Officer Tim Lynch explained to Mr. Wulff that the alarm in his car had caused him to stop and get out of his cruiser..... Within 1 hour Mr. Tim Wulff deposition appointment was cancelled......

Note: Mr. Wulff's car does not have a car alarm.

React Task Force is based in the Town of Atherton Police Department.

The question is have any law enforcement officers used the criminal computer data base without proper authority? Could any person who accessed this data base alter information?

Can't wait for the Mary Topliff Report to be made public. It will be interesting to find out who had access to the laptop computers.

Sorry, but further commenting on this topic has been closed.

Burger chain Shake Shack to open in Palo Alto
By Elena Kadvany | 18 comments | 5,018 views

The Cost of Service
By Aldis Petriceks | 1 comment | 1,220 views

Couples: When Wrong Admit It; When Right; Shut Up
By Chandrama Anderson | 0 comments | 750 views

One-on-one time
By Cheryl Bac | 0 comments | 569 views