Julian Harris scored with eight seconds remaining to play to tie the game but host Holy Names came back to beat Menlo, 86-84, on a last-second shot in a Cal Pac Conference contest Saturday night.
Harris finished with 10 points for the Oaks (5-2, 9-12), who fell out of a first-place tie in the conference. Menlo has a chance to regain a share of the lead when Cal Pac leader Cal Maritime visits the Oaks on Thursday for a 7:30 p.m. tipoff.
Drew Davis scored nine of his team-high 23 points in the final three minutes.
Menlo College outscored the host Hawks, 18-3, over the final 5:49 of Saturday's Cal Pac Conference contest, but the rally fell and Holy Names completed a 72-57 victory to move two games up on the Oaks in the conference standings.
Stephanie Truong scored 14 of her team-high 23 points during the rally for Menlo (5-2, 13-10), which had a six-game winning streak snapped.
The Oaks host Cal Maritime at 5:30 p.m. Thursday.
Menlo Colege's Brittany Caoile pinned Missouri Valley's Venus Barron in 1:38 to capture third place in the 80 kg division of the Women's College Wrestling Association Championships, hosted by Menlo.
Sherylyn Sabado finished fourth after losing, 2-1, to Oklahoma City's Kristi Garr in the 48 kg division as the Oaks finished eighth as a team.
Oklahoma City scored 117 points to win its third consecutive national title.
Women's College Wrestling Association Championships
at Haynes-Prim Pavilion, Atherton
1, Oklahoma City 117
2, Simon Fraser (British Columbia) 96
3, Cumberlands (Ky.) 66
4, King (Tenn.) 57
5, Jamestown (N.D.) 40
6, Lindenwood (Mo.), 30
7, Missouri Valley 22
8, Menlo College 16
9, Missouri Baptist 16
10, Northern Michigan 12
11, Yakima Valley (Wash.) 3
44: Nicole Woody (Oklahoma City) tech. fall Daphne-Ann Hodgson (Simon Fraser) 6-0, 7-0
48: Victoria Anthony (Simon Fraser) p. Emily Martin (King) 1:29
51: Gabrielle Henry (Cumberlands) d. Sluberski Carlene (Northern Michigan) 3-0, 3-2
55: Helen Maroulis (Simon Fraser) d. Michaela Hutchison (Oklahoma City) 7-1, 1-2, 2-1
59: Ashley Hudson (Oklahoma City) d. Cianah Hee (Cumberlands) 1-0, 3-1
63: Danielle Lappage (Simon Fraser) d. Alli Ragan (King) 5-0, 9-2
67: Kristie Davis (Oklahoma City) tech. fall Christen Paysse (Cumberlands) 6-0, 6-0
72: Mei Ling Keiki (Missouri Baptist) d. Kendra Lewis (Lindenwood) 5-0, 4-0
80: Brittany Delgado (Oklahoma City) p. Leya-Justi Luafalemana (Jamestown) 4-0, 1:04
90: Marina Lambert (King) pinned Hilary Greening (Simon Fraser) 1:46
48: Kristi Garr (Oklahoma City) d. Sherylyn Sabado (Menlo) 1-1, 1-0
80: Brittany Caoile (Menlo) p. Venus Barron (Missouri Valley) 1-0, 1:38