Atherton: Community events back, weddings still banned, in Holbrook-Palmer Park


The unintended consequences of the Atherton City Council's vote in December to end weddings and other special events in Holbrook-Palmer Park prompted the council to modify the ban to allow special community events -- such as the annual Easter Egg Hunt -- when it met last night (March 21).

The council revisited its December decision at the request of Mayor Bill Widmer and Vice Mayor Elizabeth Lewis. In a memo written to their colleagues, they noted that the decision, intended to address large events not related to the town that were preventing residents from enjoying the town's only park, was also adversely affecting residents.

"In late December 2011 a resident requested the use of Jennings Pavilion at the park for a small, 80-person memorial service for a loved one," they wrote. The denial of the request due to the newly enacted ban "highlighted the unintended consequence of the ... decision to eliminate all rentals at the park," they added.

Although the discussion began broadly, with a staff report analyzing potential revenue generated should the council allow weddings and corporate events, council members Kathy McKeithen and Jim Dobbie insisted that the topic be limited to allowing community events only to be held at the park -- the focus of the memo that led to the discussion.

A spirited discussion nevertheless took place, one that included Councilman Jerry Carlson's preferred method of managing outside special events through pricing rather than banning them outright.

It concluded with a unanimous council vote allowing events sponsored by town-designated committees and organizations, as well as birthday parties and other small celebratory events hosted by residents, to return to the park.

December's 3-2 vote to ban events in the park, with council members Carlson and Lewis dissenting, was in response to residents' complaints that they could no longer enjoy their park, particularly on weekends, because large weddings and other outside events monopolized parking and created other problems.


Like this comment
Posted by Does not add up
a resident of Atherton: West Atherton
on Mar 22, 2012 at 5:38 pm

Did that many or any residents come to a council meeting and complain that they could not use the park due to large events? More residents support renting the park for the $90,000 a year in revenue it generates to offset costs.

Decembers vote 3-2 vote banning events was to set the stage for putting the county library in the park.

Building a county library in the park will probably monopolize parking more so than a wedding.

Sorry, but further commenting on this topic has been closed.

Couples: When Wrong Admit It; When Right; Shut Up
By Chandrama Anderson | 0 comments | 849 views

One-on-one time
By Cheryl Bac | 0 comments | 605 views