News

Preschool gets priced out of Menlo Park

Rent was due to quintuple, from $9,500 to about $47,000 a month.

Casa dei Bambini, a preschool at 1215 O'Brien Drive in Menlo Park, is a hive of activity on weekdays.

Situated in the middle of the city's M-2 or "light industrial" area, the pastel-painted warehouse holds large classrooms, where 40 children ages 2-6 play and learn independently, following their interests and needs.

Some relax on the floor while others help themselves to whole-wheat bagels and banana slices at the buffet-style snack area. One little girl uses her whole arm in her brushstrokes on a painting project. Another small child in a Mandarin-English bilingual classroom colors and labels a map of the countries of South America. Meanwhile, gymnastics instructor "Ms. Melissa" sets up an indoor obstacle course to celebrate one child's birthday.

But all of that will come to a screeching halt at the end of the school year, according to a letter that the school's Director/CEO Sandra Balzaretti sent to the parents of the school on March 7. The school would be winding up a 10-year lease, and rent, she said, would quintuple.

And for the Balzaretti family, which runs the Casa dei Bambini school, a five-fold increase in rent will be a de facto eviction sentence for their Menlo Park Montessori preschool.

Ms. Balzaretti said that the proposed increase is $2.50 per square foot per month, up from 50 cents. For the 19,000-square-foot facility, that would mean a jump in monthly rent from $9,500 to about $47,000.

Family run

Casa dei Bambini, which started in Palo Alto in 1987, is a family-run school program now in its third generation of providing early education for local families.

Started by Sandra's mother Leonore, Sandra now directs the school, and her daughter, Desiree, who once attended the school, now teaches there. Her son, a financial analyst, helps manage the school's finances, as does her husband.

When they first leased the Menlo Park space in 2006, the location was a warehouse that had been previously operated by a clothing company. The vision, Ms. Balzaretti said, was to give kids generous space to play and grow. Anywhere else in Silicon Valley would be prohibitively expensive.

The Menlo Park preschool was a long time in the works. The new location was intended to relieve enrollment pressure at the school's original Palo Alto campus and reduce commute time for parents, who hailed from Menlo Park, Atherton, Woodside and Redwood City, said Sandra Balzaretti, the Palo Alto school's director. Come June, the Palo Alto school will remain open, she said, and the family will try to accommodate as many of the Menlo Park students and teachers at the Palo Alto location as possible.

Between 2006, when the Balzaretti family first sought a use permit from the city of Menlo Park for the O'Brien Drive location, and its opening in 2012, they faced down a multi-year lawsuit from local commercial real estate company Menlo Business Park, renovated and retrofitted the warehouse to be child-friendly, and even fought off a stigma to convince some families that bringing their kids across U.S. 101 to the city's warehouse district would be OK.

In 2006, the Balzarettis' proposal to open the school on O'Brien Drive went before Menlo Park's Planning Commission, which unanimously denied a use permit. The Balzaretti family appealed to the City Council, which reversed the decision and approved the permit in a 4-1 vote in February 2007.

In those city hearings, initial concerns came from landlords and business owners who said putting young kids in an industrial zone could spark health concerns and new safety regulations. Business owner John Tarlton of Menlo Business Park pushed for the application's denial, claiming the school should have to have an environmental impact review done because the building's purpose would change. He could not be reached for comment.

The arguments against the school's location, the council decided at the time, weren't sufficient deterrents. There were already a number of nearby schools in Belle Haven, there would be no real increase in traffic from the building's previous use and the city already had policies to contain potentially harmful substances and ban highly toxic chemicals near any of the schools.

Still, the Menlo Park Fire Protection District and Chamber of Commerce weighed in against the proposal. And ultimately, Menlo Business Park filed a lawsuit against the city for granting the school its use permit.

The case, Menlo Business Park v. The City of Menlo Park, ultimately reached California's 1st District Court of Appeal in San Francisco, which decided in 2010 that the school and city were not in violation of the California Environmental Quality Act. Plans for the school could move forward.

The lawsuit required paying hefty legal fees the Balzarettis struggled to meet. For the small preschool, it felt like a David-versus-Goliath battle.

"They had $150 million," said Sandra Balzaretti. "We didn't have $150,000 saved for a lawsuit."

Yet, as in the "parable of the loaves and the fishes," she said, they somehow continued to find the money to fight back.

After the school won the lawsuit, a number of retrofits and renovations had to be done. The facility shows that no kid-friendly detail has been neglected. Artwork by children's author Lisa Brown hangs from the hallways near the ground, so the kids can better view it, and there's an indoor playground.

The school

Casa dei Bambini is a private Montessori preschool that has had children of 39 nationalities, said Ms. Balzaretti. Tuition generally ranges from $12,000 to $20,000 a year, paid over 10 installments, she said, but the school is flexible with families in need. The school has a Mandarin-English language program and Spanish and French lessons, gymnastics and music classes.

The Balzaretti family had been building relationships with their neighbors, and offered full-ride scholarships to children of mothers going through JobTrain programs across the street, though no one had taken up the offer yet.

Parents, some of whom were new to the United States and struggled to connect across a language barrier, became friends and came to support one another, she said.

"This is high intensity Silicon Valley," she said. It's not the Menlo Park of the past, she said, where "people drove station wagons and wore Birkenstocks." She said many mothers and fathers of her students have highly stresful jobs and work long hours. "Families already come in crisis. Having us should be an asset," she said.

"That's what's heartbreaking," she said. "We were just at the place where we were on the right path ... (now) we are going to be leaving."

The owner of the building, Joseph Sahyoun, said he likes the school and the family, but can't afford another 10 years of renting the building so far below market rate, especially now that he's 60 years old.

By not adjusting the rent to market rate, he said he has forfeited almost half a million dollars. He said he went to bat for the school in advocating for it to receive a permit from the city, and refused to sell when Mr. Tarlton offered to buy the building.

"Frankly, I should have told them not to go there in the first place. I would have been a half million dollars better (off) and nobody would be angry," he said.

Parents upset

"This comes as a shock," said Bilal Zuberi, parent of a 7-year-old daughter who recently graduated from the school and attends public school, and a 5-year-old son, who will graduate at the end of the year.

He said a lot of Montessori schools are at smaller facilities and don't offer children as much space. Ms. Balzaretti also said that of the private schools in Menlo Park that do offer spacious land, many are parochial and have a different educational approach.

"The rich," Mr. Zuberi said, "will find other solutions." But for the kids of parents who aren't so wealthy and possibly for teachers at the school, Casa dei Bambini may no longer be an option, he said.

Mukti Naik, a Menlo Park mother of two children, 4-year-old Amey, who has attended Casa dei Bambini for three years, and 1-year-old Anay, who would be starting the school next year, says she was shocked, too.

"I would want the city to get involved to try to work with the school to ... look for another option around here somewhere," she said.

Parent Carissa Carter, whose 3-year-old son attends the school, says the news is devastating.

"A little preschool can't compete with tech companies and rising values," she said. "Who is advocating for a healthy ecosystem in our city?"

She says she's planning an optional meeting at the end of the month to rally parents to come up with ideas to help. "Mostly I feel like I cannot stand by and watch this school get mowed over," she said.

Comments

13 people like this
Posted by Member
a resident of Menlo Park: The Willows
on Mar 25, 2016 at 1:32 pm

Thanks, Facebook. Your purchase of all surrounding area for your expansion is pushing out services for the community. Now that you own all the land around your campus, how long before you expand preschool services for your own employees? How about supporting services in the general community and not just on your inwardly facing, Disney-style main street?


5 people like this
Posted by neighborly
a resident of Menlo Park: Linfield Oaks
on Mar 25, 2016 at 5:22 pm

How bout the city stop building parking garages and subsidize a project like this,

This is one property tax I would support, It would be about a dollar a year per property to keep this school operating.

Anybody live in Menlo Park and can't afford a dollar?

Any comments from the council members


9 people like this
Posted by Navin Johnson
a resident of Menlo Park: Sharon Heights
on Mar 25, 2016 at 5:43 pm

"The Market" is a cowardly excuse that landlords hide behind because they think it absolves them from the greed-driven, morally abhorrent choices they make.

"The Market" Isn't holding a gun to Mr. Sahyoun's head and forcing him raise his rent.

The only thing The Market is doing is waving a handful of cash in front of Mr. Sahyoun's face and asking the question "What are you willing to do for this?"

Mr. Sahyoun's answer: "Whatever it takes"


5 people like this
Posted by Sad
a resident of another community
on Mar 27, 2016 at 4:09 pm

It was sad enough to read that a preschool was set up in a warehouse in a "light industrial area", but then to read that such a place is raising rents and driving out these loyal tenants? That is just a Dickensian level of sad.


7 people like this
Posted by Menlo Park/County Resident
a resident of Menlo Park: Sharon Heights
on Mar 27, 2016 at 10:08 pm

Before blasting Facebook, consider that if people are civil to a valued employer, they might be willing to help the community (and I believe they have). Before blasting the landlord, keep in mind that the landlord has already sacrificed. Those complaining about the landlord - would you sell your Menlo Park home for one-tenth of its value and donate that to the school? (Probably not).

The rational suggestion is the one offered by the individual who mentioned a modest property tax. I agree we need to have a balanced lifestyle, but it can't come on the shoulders of a few individuals.

Additionally, keep in mind that you will hear objections from OTHER operators of daycares asking for their space to be subsidized. And, maybe it should be. Housing and rental space is unbelievably expensive around here and it is an issue which doesn't seem to be being fully addressed.


3 people like this
Posted by old mom
a resident of Portola Valley: other
on Mar 29, 2016 at 6:32 am

GREEDY GREEDY - Seems as tho those who hae raised the rent don't know how valuable day care is these days when both parents need to work to live in this wonderful area. I would venture to guess that the expenses the landlord incurred of late are not 5x more that they were last year at this time. The nursery school/ day care center must pay very expensive insurance plus, utilities, payroll as well as rent. Shame on you Mr. Landlord


3 people like this
Posted by Menlo Voter.
a resident of Menlo Park: other
on Mar 29, 2016 at 7:00 am

Menlo Voter. is a registered user.

Yes, shame on you Mr. Landlord for running a business as a business. You should go out of business instead.


6 people like this
Posted by MPer
a resident of Menlo Park: Central Menlo Park
on Mar 29, 2016 at 11:17 am

I love that the people here shaming a landlord for not giving this business a break would NEVER give a buyer a break when selling their over inflated home


Sorry, but further commenting on this topic has been closed.

Ice cream shop opens at Stanford Shopping Center
By Elena Kadvany | 1 comment | 5,222 views

The Last Straw
By Laura Stec | 5 comments | 2,449 views

Couples: Do you Really Agree or are you Afraid of not Agreeing?
By Chandrama Anderson | 0 comments | 1,046 views

Trying to enjoy the routines again
By Cheryl Bac | 0 comments | 542 views

 

2018 guide to summer camps

Looking for something for the kids to do this summer, learn something new and have fun? The 2018 Summer Camp Guide features local camps for all ages and interests.

Find Camps Here