This story was originally published by CalMatters. Sign up for their newsletters.
State Farm could face millions of dollars in penalties and a possible temporary suspension of its license in California as a result of hundreds of alleged law violations related to its handling of claims from the Los Angeles County fires last year.
California’s largest individual property insurance provider “showed a troubling pattern of claims handling practices” after the fires, the state’s Insurance Department said Monday. The department is seeking a hearing into the matter, which comes after an investigation it opened into State Farm’s conduct last June.
“Our investigation found that State Farm delayed, underpaid, and buried policyholders in red tape at the worst moment of their lives,” said Ricardo Lara, the state’s insurance commissioner, in a statement.
State Farm did not immediately respond to CalMatters’ questions about the department’s legal action.
If an administrative law judge finds that the 430 claims have merit, each violation is subject to up to a $5,000 penalty. Willful violations of the law are subject to penalties of up to $10,000 each. That means the company could owe about $2 million to $4.3 million. Insurers have paid billions of dollars in claims from the deadly L.A.-area fires, with State Farm saying it has paid more than $5.7 billion so far.
The insurance department opened an investigation into State Farm, which insures about a fifth of California property owners, last year after complaints from fire survivors about the company delaying and denying claims.
“Commissioner Lara calls a $2 million fine historic,” said Joy Chen, executive Director of Every Fire Survivor’s Network, a group that has called for Lara to resign, in a statement. “State Farm’s parent (company) sits on $240 billion in assets. They have the money to fulfill their obligations to L.A. fire survivors.”
The insurance department’s investigation, involving 220 claims related to the fires, found violations in 52% of them, according to the accusation filed by the department Monday. They included slow and inadequate claims investigations, underpayment, multiple claims adjusters assigned and delayed communication with policyholders. In some cases, the department asked State Farm to reopen claims and correct its violations, according to the accusation.
After a hearing, which has yet to be scheduled, any ruling by the administrative law judge will be reviewed by the commissioner. The commissioner will impose penalties and decide on whether to suspend for one year the company’s certificate of authority, which is what gives it the right to sell insurance in the state.
It’s unclear what would happen to State Farm’s customers if the company were to be suspended for a year, said Michael Soller, spokesperson for the insurance department, which has been trying to ensure that insurance companies continue to offer insurance coverage in California.
“Between the scope of the fires and the scope of this company, we’re in pretty unprecedented territory,” Soller said.
