Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...
Owner Bob Lutticken is shown behind the counter at his new wine bar. <i> Almanac photo by Michelle Le.</i>
Owner Bob Lutticken stands behind the counter after the opening of Lutticken’s After 5 in 2011. Almanac file photo by Michelle Le.

A mainstay of West Menlo Park for the past 45 years is closing. Lutticken’s Deli & After 5 Restaurant will serve its last sandwich at the end of September, Manager Judy Congdon said. 

Congdon said the business, which has been at the corner of Alameda de Las Pulgas and Gordon Avenue since it opened in 1981, has never fully recovered from the COVID-19 pandemic.

“It’s just not sustainable anymore,” said Congdon, who has worked at the restaurant since it opened. “Since COVID shut everything down, our business hasn’t come back.”

Founded by Bob Lutticken, the neighborhood deli became known for its sandwiches, particularly those served on Dutch crunch bread, and for a friendly community atmosphere where longtime customers were often greeted by name.

In 2011, the business expanded into the evening hours with Lutticken’s After 5, which served dinner and liquor. The evening restaurant hours also host live music, karaoke and open mic nights.

“It’s been an institution,” Congdon said. “We’ve had fantastic parties, wonderful customers and great kids working here. But the highlight has been just being here every day for the community.” 

State Sen. Josh Becker, D-Menlo Park, and San Mateo County Supervisor Ray Mueller celebrate Lutticken’s Deli & After 5 Restaurant as the District 13 Small Business of the Year in 2024. Courtesy Josh Becker.

Lutticken’s supported local organizations and causes over its decades in business, including youth sports teams and groups providing food to people in need. During the early months of the COVID-19 pandemic, the business raised more than $6,000 to help provide assistance to local residents.

Lutticken’s was recognized by state Sen. Josh Becker, who named the restaurant Senate District 13’s 2024 Small Business of the Year. 

Becker’s not the only politician with an appreciation for the deli. In June 2000, then-Vice President Al Gore stopped at Lutticken’s while campaigning for president, getting a turkey sandwich and meeting with Peninsula business owners. The visit, accompanied by police and Secret Service agents, came as a surprise to customers and even to Lutticken himself, who was given about two hours to prepare.

The last day for the original Lutticken’s on Alameda de Las Pulgas will be on Sept. 30. The deli’s two satellite locations, on the Stanford University campus and Sand Hill Road, are also set to close in September.

Arden Margulis is a reporter for The Almanac, covering Menlo Park and Atherton. He first joined the newsroom in May 2024 as an intern. His reporting on the Las Lomitas School District won first place coverage...

Leave a comment